What’s the outlook for college fossil fuel divestment?


This audio is auto-generated. Please tell us when you have feedback.

When Harvard College introduced final fall that it will be divesting its endowment from the fossil fuel industry, it was a part of a deluge.

Roughly 20 faculties and universities introduced final 12 months that they might be divesting their endowments from the fossil gas trade, according to a list maintained by environmental teams. These included the California State College System, Dartmouth Faculty, Amherst Faculty and the College of Michigan.

This 12 months, that momentum appeared to have slowed barely — at the very least earlier than a surprise legislative breakthrough this month upended circumstances by clearing the trail for a federal local weather invoice. Market adjustments would possibly imply that faculties are extra reluctant to go “fossil free” within the brief time period, specialists say. However the basic pressures to divest usually are not prone to go anyplace, and so they could also be getting stronger.

The inventory market

One issue at the moment impacting willingness to divest is the inventory market. When the market is excessive, faculties could discover it simpler to divest, mentioned Christopher Marsicano, assistant professor of academic research and public policy at Davidson Faculty. That’s not solely as a result of faculties can get a greater return on fossil gas shares in the event that they promote when the market is excessive, however as a result of it could be simpler to get buy-in from constituents, equivalent to alumni.

In different phrases, the excessive inventory market in 2021 possible contributed to the flood of divestment bulletins.

“It’s very easy in good monetary years to announce large adjustments to your endowment portfolio,” Marsicano mentioned. “When your endowment worth has elevated at a excessive charge, you may divest and even when you have a loss in some areas, the expansion of the market will offset that loss, such that it turns into simpler to promote to your alumni or people who find themselves involved about it.”

Fears of a recession and the rising demand for gas could in flip disincentivize establishments from divesting, particularly these with above-average investments in fossil fuels, mentioned CJ Ryan, affiliate professor on the College of Louisville’s regulation faculty.

“I’d predict that these universities which might be on the fence about divestment could keep there to journey out the current inflationary curve and the (very possible) coming recession,” he mentioned through e mail.

Political stress

Some establishments could have already chosen to divest however are retaining that reality near the chest to keep away from political confrontation, Marsicano mentioned. As sustainable investing has grown, there was a conservative backlash in opposition to it. West Virginia and Texas, for instance, have handed legal guidelines limiting state companies from doing enterprise with monetary corporations which have pledged to divest from fossil fuels. College donors could react negatively to divestment, particularly at establishments in states with giant power sectors. 

Monetary managers typically aren’t occupied with partaking in hot-button political points, Marsicano mentioned. In the event that they need to, they’ll divest quietly, with out drawing consideration to themselves.

“It’s a comparatively simple factor to do over time with out an announcement.” Marsicano mentioned. “We simply don’t really know what number of faculties have really divested.”

However the stress to divest might be not going away for faculties and universities. For one factor, scholar enthusiasm and activism appears unlikely to subside. And campaigns are actually armed with a rising physique of information to indicate that divestment is a secure, fiduciary alternative.

The monetary observe document

Amy Grey, senior local weather finance strategist at Stand.earth, a nonprofit advocating for divestment, mentioned that campaigns are more and more making use of economic knowledge and research, as a result of they’ve realized that’s what cash managers and decision-makers will reply to.

“We hope that they might transfer on an ethical crucial, however lots of instances they transfer extra on financial arguments,” she mentioned. “When you begin speaking cash to them, that’s after they begin listening, and that’s after they begin altering their methods.”

A 2020 study Ryan and Marsicano co-wrote discovered that divestment didn’t negatively affect endowment worth for increased ed establishments. And final 12 months, a report by the monetary agency BlackRock, commissioned by the New York Metropolis lecturers’ pension system, concluded that a number of methods could be a “appropriate divestment strategy” for the fund. 

“The power sector is the one one which faces severe questions on its long-term existence.”

placeholder 200

Dan Cohn

International power transition researcher on the Institute for Vitality Economics and Monetary Evaluation

The rising variety of monetary corporations and pension funds which have chosen to divest may additionally add stress to schools. Although increased ed could not see these establishments as friends, the actions of big-name corporations and funds could undercut faculties’ skill to make use of fiduciary responsibility as a cause to proceed investing in fossil gas.

“We’ve now handed an inflection level the place the actions taken by some very severe buyers present that divestment from fossil fuels is completely per assembly divestment targets and fulfilling fiduciary responsibility,” mentioned Dan Cohn, international power transition researcher on the Institute for Vitality Economics and Monetary Evaluation, which has advocated for divestment. “The monetary logic that underpinned divestment from the get-go has been endorsed to a point by people who find themselves not pushed by an ethical concern about local weather change.” 

Share post:



More like this